Wednesday, August 20, 2008

A Game You Can't Win

Recently I've been playing a nice browser based MMO called Travian. In the game you start out with a randomly located village. You upgrade your resource fields, construct buildings and infrastructure, create armies, band together in alliances, and so on. It's quite fun, albeit a little slow paced at times.

There's this guy in my 7X7 grid who's been raiding my village every day to get resources. At first I panicked, but then I came up with a plan and started slowly rebuilding my defensive buildings. I had founded another village a few weeks before, which I then converted into a nice little military base. I trained about 570 troops there, and about 400 in my main village, shipping them there. When I had an army, I sent all the troops to defend the main village. They held up for about 6 hours.

He sent a few of his normal attacks, consisting of 300 or so troops that I could easily wipe out. Someone from my alliance sent me some reinforcements to make the army extra strong and I thought I was all set. I replaced the few troops he managed to take out and went to work. When I got home all of my troops were dead, my wall had been destroyed, and the guy stole about 20,000 of my resources. All the strategy and effort I put into making sure my village didn't remain a farm was for nothing.

It's kind of a parallel of my life.

Two months ago, I though I was in a really good financial situation so I completely paid off my student loan and made large payments on my credit cards. Immediately, my hours at work got cut by 30%. This month I got a 50 cent raise, which I certainly wasn't expecting. Even though it's not a huge raise it does make a significant difference and I thought I could take advantage of that to quickly pay the remaining balance on my credit cards. But life happens.

I thought going to Baker college would help me get a great (paying) job within a few years. I put an enormous amount of effort into everything I did there and quickly won the recognition of my instructors, but then I ran out of money and dropped out (not really in that order). In reality, it put me in a hole that I just now, four years later, got out of. I thought moving to Chesterfield would give me a chance to save some money to go back to college. I put enormous amounts of effort into my work and trying to make living here as pleasant as possible for everyone, but I'm just digging myself into a new hole that will take another four years to climb out of.

Some days it just seems like no matter what I do and no matter how much effort I put into everything I do, the world just keeps pounding on me and nothing changes. Nothing gets better. Things only stay the same or get worse. Maybe I'm making all the wrong choices. Or maybe I'm making the right choices, but taking the wrong actions. Either way I'm doing something wrong. All I know is that there's no point playing a game you can't win unless you have fun doing so.

4 comments :

  1. Bah. Learn from Sun Tzu, Napoleon and Dick Cheney: Defense is based on reaction. It is far too easy to let your enemy control the way of the battle.

    You have your alliance, and you have your home base. Allow your enemy to raid with only minor defense, which you amass resources. Forget about defensive structures for now.

    Then, when you're ready, co-ordinate a strike against your enemy, on three different outposts. Then raid his capital, making sure he knows it's you that did it. Let your offensive become a display of power, even if it's just a bluff.

    Then go the NATO route; I don't know if that's how the game works, but setting up outposts on his territory is a good way to buffer against further invasion.

    You could also sacrifice some of your own territory to a more powerful ally, using his/her strength as a shield between you and your enemies.

    Can you tell that I'm a strategy gamer?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I wish I was a decent strategist. Every time I think I've got the guy beat, he one ups me with his enormous army. There's really nothing I can do except for building up my troops until I have more than him, which won't be possible because he has 6 villages and I only have 2. I guess I need to go colonize.

    ReplyDelete
  3. My most favored strategy for settlement is to keep my capital in the center, so that my empire acts as a buffer and my capital (usually with the highest production values) can send out troops en masse to all places equally. Of course, this setup has a weakness (which I've already mentioned). If I don't have the resources to maintain an appropriately sized army, I'll be spread too thin. A co-ordinated multi-point strike will destroy me, like the Goths destroyed Rome.

    Another thing to do is to copy the Mongolians; you can ensure your own survival by constantly raiding others, so that even if your resources are being stolen in one village, you're still breaking even, enough to keep putting out your military.

    Most of my strategic knowledge comes from the Art of War, and also Machiavelli's Il Principe.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Oh, right. The bigger problem.

    I don't see where other people are coming into your strategy, which indicates that you may be trying to go at this alone (even if only by mentality). Caesar was nothing without his army.

    Don't let your debts hold you back. Ask for more hours at work, or even take a second job to make up for it. Then consolidate your debt so that you only have one interest rate to deal with.

    The uphill struggle can be tough, especially when you don't have as many people pulling you up. But rest assured, every mountain has its summit. Once you reach it, everything is downhill from there.

    ReplyDelete